Click here to learn more
 

Click Here to Shop  -- Meridian Marketplace

LDSGetaway.com
LDSPro.com




Click here to find out more






Share the article on this page with a friend.
Click here.
Meridian Magazine : : Home

As I began writing this at 7:02 a.m. Pacific time, no one knew who John McCain's vice presidential pick will be. The official announcement will be at 9:00 a.m. (noon Eastern time) in Dayton, Ohio.

Alaska Governor Sarah Palin was rumored to be somewhere in Ohio, and the McCain campaign has just confirmed that she is his choice.

Mitt Romney had a reception for major donors last night in West Los Angeles. He told the crowd, “I honestly don't know, and that should tell you everything you need to know.”

It appears that until right now, no one but a few John McCain insiders knew who the pick would be. If Senator McCain's goal was to create suspense and draw attention away from Senator Barack Obama's acceptance speech in Denver last night, he sure seems to have succeeded.

Others will have much to say about Sarah Palin as the choice. Personally, I like her.

But right now my mind is reflecting on the whole Mitt Romney for President drama, from the perspective of a Latter-day Saint who has been following the drama, from the perspective of our faith and how it is perceived in the United States, for the last 27 months. It's all there at Article VI Blog.

The question that has been rolling around in my head this week is, Where are the denunciations?

In other words, as outrageous things have been said about Governor Romney's active, committed membership in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, what has truly struck me is that no national leader seems to have come forward and denounced what is undeniably religious bigotry.

I hate to play the victim card. It is not something we Mormons do. We are not victims. Our church is now the fourth-largest denomination in the United States , and we are not going away anytime soon.

Even so, it is simply remarkable that statements may be made about our faith and its members that would not be tolerated about any other faith. Back in September 2006, for example, a McCain supporter in South Carolina named Cyndi Mosteller confronted Governor Romney and manufactured a news media story::

Cyndi Mosteller, chairwoman of the Charleston County Republican Party, one of the largest GOP organizations in the state, came armed with a bunch of material — and questions — about the Mormon church. . . . 

Mosteller, an evangelical, said she especially was concerned about the church's attitude toward African-Americans and its stand on polygamy . . . .

Mosteller said the issues of race and marriage concern her. She fears they could become campaign issues and hurt Republican chances....  

Afterward, Mosteller said the governor did not answer any of her questions. She described the meeting as “very tense.”  [Emphasis mine.]

To me, Ms. Mosteller's stunt was not the story; the deafening silence from John McCain was. The Senator never disavowed Cyndi Mosteller's comments.

Another example: Joel Belz is the editor of World Magazine, perhaps the most widely-read Evangelical publication. Mr. Belz wrote an astonishing World piece, “Trifling with the truth,” in which he argued that Mitt Romney's changes in position on some major issues (“flip-flops”) were easy to understand, because Mormonism is a faith that, well, doesn't tell the truth:

It's not a trivial matter that Mormonism, as a cultic movement, has a bad reputation when it comes to getting its own story straight. Check out the public record, if you will, including fairly recent interviews with Mormon officials in venues like Larry King Live, 60 Minutes, and Newsweek. Do these officials hold to the fantastical 1827 golden tablets of Mormon founder Joseph Smith—or not? Well, they seem to say: We believe it when we want to, and we don't when it's less convenient. Where Mormonism isn't shrouded in deliberate secrecy, it is covered with confusion.

So when folks tell me they're satisfied that Mitt Romney won't try to drag his Mormonism into his politics, and that he would never ever impose his theology on the American people, I have to worry whether that's exactly what he's already done. When, in a relatively short space of time, he seems to be on both sides of the same issue—and when such a deviously confusing approach seems to be consistent with his faith rather than counter to it—that sets off alarm bells for me.

Only a few weeks ago, I sat a dozen feet from Romney as he compellingly spelled out his convictions and credentials. He was winsome and persuasive. On the surface, he said almost everything I want to hear my candidate say. On the issues that matter (except for choice in education), he was as convincing as any politician I've heard in recent years.

But still.

More than anything, I want a president who tells the truth. And I worry deeply when people are overly ready to believe a man whose religious upbringing, of all things, suggests that the truth is a negotiable commodity.

If you're like me, those paragraphs alternately enrage you and shock you.

But again, I've never seen anyone denounce them.

Speaking of outrageous statements about Mitt Romney's Mormonism, Mike Huckabee got into lots of trouble for asking a New York Times reporter, “Don't Mormons believe Jesus and Satan are brothers?” A couple of days ago Huckabee appeared on Rush Limbaugh's show, and this exchange occurred:

RUSH: Thank you. So are you, sir. Now let's get right to the chase here. I said something a couple weeks ago, maybe ten days ago, about you and Governor Romney that you strenuously objected to. What was it that I said that was incorrect?

HUCKABEE: Well, that I had made an issue out of his religion and had sort of poisoned him with evangelicals and that's simply not true. You know, one of the things that I've been very adamant about is that I don't think his religion has one thing to do with whether people should support him. Some of my favorite public servants in America happen to be the same religion he is, the Morman religion. That would be people like Mike Leavitt, Orrin Hatch, Jon Huntsman, the current governor of Utah . Great people. It has nothing to do with it.

RUSH: Yeah, but they're not running for president nor running against you for the nomination. I guess I track this back to at one point you talking about what Romney believes, that Christ and Lucifer were brothers.

HUCKABEE: It was a question that I actually asked of the New York Times Magazine writer, because he knew a lot more about Mormonism than I did. It appeared as 11 words in about a 10,000-word story, and that got all the play. I personally apologized to Mitt because it did come across wrong and it's simply not the way I feel and it isn't, and I don't think Mitt Romney's religion has a thing to do with it. I think, you know, a record has to do with it, but not his religion. And frankly, my attitude is, the primary's over, we need to get behind John McCain, support him, He's our best chance, right now, our only chance to beat Barack Obama, and Barack Obama will destroy small business, his plans for higher taxes would be abominable, and his absolutely frankly deplorable view about when life begins is nothing short of frightening.

Once again: That's fine, as far as it goes, but what about the comments on Huckabee's own web site (which were not removed) referring to Mitt Romney as "Mormon garbage?" I wonder if comments calling Senator Joseph Lieberman a "sneaky Jew" would have been left on the site.

And that is what interests me: the absence of denunciation or disavowal. Governor Huckabee seems to have always put on the most innocent of airs about his own comments, but he has never been able to bring himself to say anything at all about the ugly comments of his supporters, much less denounce or disavow them. This seems to me undeniable.

It continues to amaze me that in the United States of America the general response to such repulsive speech has been silence, which I think is born of outright cowardice.

But now we will move on. Mitt Romney will enthusiastically support the McCain-Palin ticket. Personally, I will too. I will always be proud of the way Governor Romney represented our faith in the most difficult of public arenas. He is the most decent, intelligent, and kind man I have ever seen run for any office anywhere, I wish him the nothing but blessing and great things in the future. I hope he has a chance to serve our nation in some significant manner.

Meanwhile, we Mormons need to be glad we had such a fine person reflecting our highest aspirations for family and public service. We all owe a debt to the Romneys for what they have done. And we all need to shake off the feelings of anger and disappointment and surprise over the less attractive side of America we saw during the campaign. I'm convinced those indefensible attitudes and statements come from a very small segment of America . I hope we will all simply soldier on, living our religion and serving. Opposition may always be there, but . . . so will the Latter-day Saints.

Return to Top of Article

Click here to sign up for Meridian's FREE email updates.


©1999- 2008 Meridian Magazine.  All Rights Reserved.

About the Author:

Lowell C. Brown is co-author of Article VI Blog, http://www.article6blog.com, which is devoted to discussion and analysis of the religious issues surrounding the 2008 presidential election. Lowell is also a Los Angeles-based attorney who is a partner in Arent Fox LLP, where he practices corporate health law for institutional health care providers. He describes himself as an active, committed, convinced Mormon and has served in a number of callings in the Church, his favorite of which was Scoutmaster. The views expressed here are Lowell's own.

Related Resources:

Ideas and Society Archive

Click here to learn more and to buy

We are living in an unprecedented time in the history of the Church. All of us are witnesses to the greatest temple-building era in the history of the world! Now, documented on DVD, Meridian brings you Gordon B. Hinckley
Temple Builder, Up Front and Personal. Meridian's founders, Scot & Maurine Proctor, invite you right to a front row seat of temple dedications and significant events with President Hinckley all over the world. With stunning photography, powerful video clips from conference and beautiful music, the experience will inspire you and lift you bring you to tears. More than a million Latter-day Saints have read some of these accounts on Meridian Now they come to you on DVD. All for only $16.50.
Click here to buy.

What do you think?
Format for Print
Click Here